Litigation Case Manager/Paralegal at Hensley Legal Group, PC

Fishers, Indiana, United States -

Full Time

Start Date

Immediate

Expiry Date

15 May, 26

Salary

0.0

Posted On

14 Feb, 26

Experience

2 year(s) or above

Remote Job

Yes

Telecommute

Yes

Sponsor Visa

Skills

Case Management, Litigation Support, Client Communication, Deadline Management, Pleadings Drafting, Discovery Coordination, Motion Drafting, Trial Preparation, Case Notes Maintenance, Time Management, Project Management, Attention To Detail, Proactive Communication, Critical Thinking, Caseload Ownership, Legal Assistant Duties

Industry

Legal Services

Description

Description Are you energized by managing complex cases, keeping deadlines on track, and playing a central role in litigation strategy? Do you thrive when balancing client communication, detailed casework, and fast-moving court schedules? We’re looking for a Litigation Case Manager/Paralegal to partner closely with our Litigation Attorneys and help drive personal injury cases from active litigation through resolution. Who We Are HLG is dedicated to making a difference in the lives of people who have been injured or disabled. What we do every day, with each individual client, positively impacts them as they face some of their most difficult times. Making a difference is what drives every member of this team, and it makes us one of the preeminent firms in our industry. We are growing fast and looking for people who aren’t afraid of a challenge nor of going the extra mile – because our clients deserve it. If you’re looking for more than a daily grind where what you do matters, we’re looking for you. What You’ll Do As a Litigation Case Manager/Paralegal, you will maintain an active caseload and serve as a key driver in ensuring each matter progresses efficiently and strategically toward mediation, settlement, or trial. You will be a primary point of contact for clients while working side-by-side with Litigation Attorneys to keep every detail aligned and on schedule. Your day-to-day work will include: Serving as the client’s primary point of contact, conducting status calls every 30–45 days to check on treatment and provide case updates. Managing litigation deadlines, including setting reminders for motions, pleadings, discovery, and court requirements. Drafting and filing standard motions and pleadings in a timely manner. Completing and coordinating discovery, including plaintiff discovery, standard discovery to defendants, and non-party discovery (e.g., cell phone carriers, defense experts, insurance carriers). Preparing medical binders and organizing evidence for mediation and trial. Scheduling depositions and mediation. Verifying and addressing potential liens. Ensuring all discovery is received and answered prior to depositions. Delegating medical records, billing, and balance requests to the Legal Assistant and overseeing follow-through. Reviewing incoming mail and ensuring appropriate action or attorney review. Maintaining detailed case notes in the case management system in accordance with firm procedures. Following established trial preparation checklists and notifying the Litigation Attorney of any case developments or concerns. Closing cases in the system upon final settlement or satisfaction of judgment. This role requires strong ownership of your caseload, consistent communication, and a commitment to keeping cases moving forward without sacrificing accuracy. Who You Are You’re organized, adaptable, and confident in managing multiple priorities at once. You take initiative and understand that litigation is deadline-driven and detail-heavy, requiring both precision and proactive communication. You bring strong time management and project management skills, a sharp attention to detail, and the self-motivation to handle a substantial caseload in a fast-paced environment. You think critically, anticipate next steps, and communicate consistently and professionally with clients, attorneys, court staff, and opposing counsel. Above all, you take pride in keeping complex cases organized, documented, and moving forward smoothly. You bring: High School Diploma or GED required Associate’s or Bachelor’s degree preferred Prior legal experience, particularly in personal injury litigation, strongly preferred Proven ability to manage deadlines, documentation, and client communication in a professional setting Why You’ll Love It Here We offer a supportive, in-office team that values collaboration along with: A comprehensive benefits package that includes medical, dental, and vision benefits, paid time off, 401k, paid parental leave, and pet benefit discount program. A flexible schedule designed around core hours. The chance to build a stable career as a legal assistant while doing work that truly matters. Participating in a firm that recognizes effort, encourages growth, and celebrates the impact our work has on real people. If you’re ready to take ownership of cases, support meaningful litigation work, and grow your career as a Litigation Case Manager/Paralegal, we’d love to meet you. Special consideration will be given to resumes submitted with a cover letter. Apply today and take the next step in a career where your commitment to justice truly matters.

Responsibilities

The Litigation Case Manager/Paralegal will maintain an active caseload, serving as the primary client contact and driving each personal injury matter efficiently toward resolution via mediation, settlement, or trial. Key duties include managing litigation deadlines, drafting and filing standard motions, coordinating discovery, preparing evidence for hearings, and overseeing case progression.