Y-Axis Jobs Logo
Send us feedback
telephone  +91 7670 800 001
Log in Sign up Try Premium

Jobs in Norway

About 1244 results in (1) seconds Clear Filters

Jobs Search

About 1244 results in (1) seconds
Freelance AI Evaluation Engineer (Python/Full-Stack) at Mindrift
, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Python, Full Stack, Testing, Evaluation, Ai Systems, Coding Test Cases, Functional Tests, Edge Cases, React, Back End, Pytest, Async/Await, Subprocess, File Operations, Docker, Ci/Cd
Specialization
Candidates should be experienced developers, software engineers, or test automation specialists open to part-time, non-permanent projects, ideally holding a degree in a related technical field. A minimum of 5 years of software development experience, primarily in Python, along with Full-Stack background (React and Back-end), and experience writing various types of tests are required.
Experience Required
Minimum 5 year(s)
Change Management Excellence Manager at Wallenius Wilhelmsen Ocean AS
Bærum, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Change Management Strategy, Stakeholder Engagement, Communication, Training, Organizational Development, Digital Transformation, Process Optimization, Leadership, Interpersonal Skills, Governance, Best Practices, Measurement, Continuous Improvement, Technology Adoption, Data Enabled Decision Making, Cross Functional Collaboration
Specialization
Candidates must possess a minimum of a bachelor's degree in a relevant field and over 6 years of experience in change management, project management, or business transformation, including driving change in digital environments. Strong leadership, communication, and interpersonal skills are essential for influencing stakeholders at all levels.
Experience Required
Minimum 5 year(s)
Renhold-tilkallingsvikarer Trondheim og omegn at Ability
Trondheim, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Daily Cleaning, Periodic Cleaning, Main Cleaning, Service Tasks, Outdoor Maintenance, Indoor Maintenance, Shopping Cart Maintenance, Insta 800 Standard, Service Minded, Flexible, Reliable, Efficient, Responsible, Approachable, Good Humor, Good Physical Shape
Specialization
Candidates should ideally possess a vocational certificate as a cleaning operator or have relevant experience in cleaning, along with familiarity with the INSTA 800 standard. Fluency in Norwegian or English, both spoken and written, and a driver's license are also required.
Senior Marketing Manager at PA Knowledge Limited - Denmark
Oslo, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
B2b Marketing, Integrated Campaigns, Stakeholder Management, Digital Marketing, Event Management, Public Relations, Content Strategy, Commercial Instincts, Strategic Planning, Brand Building, Marketing Operations, Crm, Account Based Marketing, Project Management, Analytical Skills, Communication
Specialization
Candidates must have 4–6 years of B2B marketing experience, preferably within professional services or consulting. Proficiency in both Norwegian and English is required, along with a strong track record in delivering integrated campaigns across digital, PR, and event channels.
Experience Required
Minimum 5 year(s)
Selger 100% Vikariat JYSK Tromsø at JYSK
Tromsø, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Sales, Customer Service, Teamwork, Initiative, Goal Orientation, Flexibility, Positive Energy, Communication In Norwegian, Area Responsibility
Specialization
The ideal candidate is outgoing, enjoys talking to people, possesses positive energy, takes initiative, loves sales, and thrives on working towards common goals. Applicants must be able to understand and be understood in Norwegian and be prepared for evening and Saturday work.
Global Process Owner Record to Report at BearingPoint United Kingdom
Oslo, Oslo, Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Record To Report, Financial Close, General Ledger, Consolidation, Reporting, Sap S/4hana, Ifrs, Process Harmonisation, Process Standardisation, Change Management, Audit, Financial Accounting, Controlling, Signavio, Process Mining, Automation
Specialization
Candidates must hold a master's degree in a business or economics discipline and possess at least five years of professional experience in accounting, controlling, or audit. Strong expertise in SAP S/4HANA, IFRS, and process governance is required, along with fluent English communication skills.
Experience Required
Minimum 5 year(s)
Telecom - Senior/Principal engineer Bergen at Statoil ASA – Norway
Bergen, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Design, Studies, Estimation, Job Packages, Discipline Check, Supplier Follow Up, Pre Test, Fat, Inspections, Training, As Built, Telecom System, Network Infrastructure, Fiber Optic Technologies, Atex, Norsok
Specialization
Candidates need a Bachelor's or Master's degree in Telecom/Instrumentation/Automation, or equivalent technical college degree with extensive experience in Norwegian Oil and Gas engineering projects. A minimum of 5 years of experience in offshore-related projects and strong engineering design skills are required, along with knowledge of relevant industry standards and telecommunication technologies.
Experience Required
Minimum 5 year(s)
Partner Business IT Solutions and Business Development - Northern EU - Insu at SAP Fioneer
, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Business Solution, Business Development, Insurance Industry, C Suite Engagement, Trusted Advisor, Technical Challenge Identification, Business Driver Understanding, Solution Co Creation, Transformation Projects, Portfolio Utilization, Stakeholder Collaboration, Process Analysis, Industry Knowledge, It Solutions, Solution Selling, Business Acumen
Specialization
Candidates must possess a minimum of 8 years of experience delivering IT solutions for strategic and transformational initiatives within insurance companies. Essential qualifications include a Master's degree (MBA/PhD preferred) and deep expertise in Core Insurance software, coupled with a strong network among C-Suite executives in the UK and North Europe.
Experience Required
Minimum 10 year(s)
Joker Reinslettveien søker butikkmedarbeider - deltid at NorgesGruppen
Bodø, Nordland, Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Customer Service, Cashier Work, Stock Replenishment, Physical Stamina, Communication, Teamwork, Problem Solving, Creativity, Retail Operations
Specialization
Candidates must be at least 18 years old and possess strong Norwegian language skills. Previous experience in grocery or retail is preferred but not required, and the ability to work evenings, weekends, and holidays is essential.
KIWI Flymuseet søker etter butikkmedarbeider deltid 80 % at NorgesGruppen
, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Customer Service, Punctuality, Orderliness, Positive Attitude, Work Capacity, Honesty, Responsibility, Reliability, Competitive Instinct
Specialization
Candidates must be at least 18 years old, punctual, and organized. You should possess a positive service attitude, high work capacity, and be honest and responsible.
Senior nettverksingeniør at Sopra Steria
Stavanger, Rogaland, Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Network Engineering, Scripting, Automation, Sd Wan, Vmware Nsx, Cisco Aci, Fortinet, Python, Ansible, Terraform, Network Modernization, Network Optimization, English Communication, Norwegian Communication
Specialization
Candidates should have a higher education degree and 4+ years of relevant experience, preferably with a CCNA certification. Proficiency in automation tools like Python or Ansible and knowledge of SD-WAN or Cisco ACI is highly valued.
Experience Required
Minimum 5 year(s)
Sales Advisor - Oslo Fornebu (sommerhjelp) at Rituals
Bærum, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Customer Experience, Teamwork, Sales Guidance, Visual Merchandising, Safety Procedures, Retail, Customer Service, Problem Solving, Decision Making, Organization, Norwegian, English
Specialization
Candidates must be passionate about creating a magical customer experience, connecting genuinely with customers, and acting as a professional brand ambassador. Required qualifications include relevant retail/customer service/health experience, a results-oriented mindset, strong decision-making skills, attention to detail, and very good proficiency in Norwegian and English.
Securitas søker vekter til NAV kontor (Intern) at Securitas USA Corporate Services
Oslo, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Security Monitoring, Reception Services, Patrol Rounds, Reporting, Incident Handling, Customer Service, Independent Work, Teamwork, Professionalism, Initiative, Structured, Reliable, Technical Aptitude, System Handling
Specialization
The ideal candidate must be independent, confident, mature, proactive, structured, and reliable, possessing a good security mindset to understand client needs and make sound decisions. Fluency in Norwegian and English (minimum B2 for Norwegian) is mandatory, along with a security guard education, clean criminal record, a Class B driver's license, and access to a private car.
Salgsmedarbeider 25% JYSK Sandvika at JYSK
Sandvika, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Customer Service, Sales Activities, Product Knowledge, Cash Register Operation, Merchandising, Stock Management, Teamwork, Communication, Norwegian, English, Physical Stamina
Specialization
Candidates must possess excellent customer service and strong sales skills, along with good communication abilities in both Norwegian and English. The role requires the ability to work in a fast-paced retail environment, handle transactions accurately, and be physically capable of standing for long periods and lifting goods.
Sesonghjelp sommer MATCH Farmandstredet at Decades
Tønsberg, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Customer Service, Sales, Fashion Knowledge, Trend Awareness, Communication, Interpersonal Skills
Specialization
Candidates should have completed high school and possess sales experience within the retail industry. A strong interest in fashion and trends, along with a social and welcoming personality, is required.
Kundekonsulent | Fastlønn + Bonus | Norico AS at Workation AS
Oslo, Oslo, Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Customer Service, Sales, Communication Skills, Order Handling, Relationship Building, Teamwork, Pc Proficiency, Telephone Etiquette
Specialization
Candidates should be outgoing with strong verbal and written communication skills and a service-minded attitude. Experience in customer service is a plus, but the company encourages young applicants eager to learn.
Burger King Orkanger søker fulltidsansatt at Burger King Norge
Orkanger, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Customer Service, Teamwork, Food Preparation, Communication, Initiative, Time Management
Specialization
The candidate should be a positive 'yes-person' who is available to work days, evenings, and weekends. A strong desire to provide 100% effort in guest service is more important than a fancy CV.
Sesonghjelp sommer MATCH Jærhagen at Decades
Klepp, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Customer Service, Sales, Fashion Knowledge, Trend Awareness, Communication, Interpersonal Skills
Specialization
Candidates should have completed high school and possess a strong interest in fashion and trends. Previous sales experience in a similar retail industry is preferred.
Ledig stilling som BPA-assistent: Bli min viktige støttespiller! at Humana omsorg og assistanse
Oslo, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Personal Care, Patient Transfer, Communication, Patient Advocacy, Social Activation, Hygiene Care, Feeding Tube Management, Patience, Reliability, Norwegian Language Proficiency
Specialization
Candidates must have strong oral and written Norwegian skills and be comfortable with personal care and lifting equipment. Experience with people with disabilities or wheelchair handling is an advantage but not required as training is provided.
Butikkmedarbeidere i 25% stilling til Musti Jessheim Senter! at Musti Norge AS
Jessheim, Viken, Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Sales, Customer Service, Upselling, Animal Care, Teamwork, Communication
Specialization
Candidates must be over 18 with retail experience, preferably in sales, and have a passion for or experience with dogs and cats. An energetic, outgoing personality and a positive attitude toward competition are required.
Freelance AI Evaluation Engineer (Python/Full-Stack) at Mindrift
, , Norway -
Full Time

Start Date

Immediate

Expiry Date

27 Jun, 26

Salary

50.0

Posted On

29 Mar, 26

Experience

5 year(s) or above

Remote Job

Yes

Telecommute

Yes

Sponsor Visa

No

Skills

Python, Full-Stack, Testing, Evaluation, AI Systems, Coding Test Cases, Functional Tests, Edge-Cases, React, Back-end, Pytest, Async/Await, Subprocess, File Operations, Docker, CI/CD

Industry

technology;Information and Internet

Description
Please submit your CV in English and indicate your level of English proficiency. Mindrift connects specialists with project-based AI opportunities for leading tech companies, focused on testing, evaluating, and improving AI systems. Participation isproject-based, not permanent employment. What this opportunity involves You’ll create challenging coding test cases that push AI coding systems to their limits: Review and refine realistic coding tasks based on provided production codebases with realistic scope, requirements and information sources Write comprehensive functional tests that validate actual end-to-end behavior and edge-cases, not just superficial checks Craft “fair but hard” challenges where the AI has all the context it needs, but has to work for it (information scattered across files and external sources, complex reasoning required) Analyze AI failures to understand what the model struggles with vs. what it masters Iterate based on feedback from expert QA reviewers who score your work on 7 quality criteria What we look for This opportunity is a good fit for experienced developers, software engineers, and/or test automation specialists open to part-time, non-permanent projects. Ideally, contributors will have: Degree in Computer Science, Software Engineering or related fields 5+ years in software development, primarily Python (pytest, async/await, subprocess, file operations) Background in Full-Stack development, with an equal focus on building React-based interfaces and robust Back-end systems Experience writing tests (functional, integration – not just running them) Docker containers (running evaluations locally in containers) CI/CD understanding (GitHub Actions as a user: triggers, labels, reading results) English proficiency - B2 How it works Apply → Pass qualification(s) → Join a project → Complete tasks → Get paid Effort estimate Tasks for this project are estimated to take 20 hours to complete, depending on complexity. This is an estimate and not a schedule requirement; you choose when and how to work. Tasks must be submitted by the deadline and meet the listed acceptance criteria to be accepted. Compensation On this project, contributors can earn up to $50 per hour equivalent, depending on their level and pace of contribution. Compensation varies across projects depending on scope, complexity, and required expertise. Please note that other projects on the platform may offer different earning levels based on their requirements.

How To Apply:

Incase you would like to apply to this job directly from the source, please click here

Responsibilities
The role involves creating challenging coding test cases to push AI coding systems to their limits by reviewing and refining realistic coding tasks based on production codebases. Responsibilities also include writing comprehensive functional tests to validate end-to-end behavior and analyzing AI failures to understand model strengths and weaknesses.
Freelance AI Evaluation Engineer (Python/Full-Stack) at Mindrift
, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Python, Full Stack, Testing, Evaluation, Ai Systems, Coding Test Cases, Functional Tests, Edge Cases, React, Back End, Pytest, Async/Await, Subprocess, File Operations, Docker, Ci/Cd
Specialization
Candidates should be experienced developers, software engineers, or test automation specialists open to part-time, non-permanent projects, ideally holding a degree in a related technical field. A minimum of 5 years of software development experience, primarily in Python, along with Full-Stack background (React and Back-end), and experience writing various types of tests are required.
Experience Required
Minimum 5 year(s)
Change Management Excellence Manager at Wallenius Wilhelmsen Ocean AS
Bærum, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Change Management Strategy, Stakeholder Engagement, Communication, Training, Organizational Development, Digital Transformation, Process Optimization, Leadership, Interpersonal Skills, Governance, Best Practices, Measurement, Continuous Improvement, Technology Adoption, Data Enabled Decision Making, Cross Functional Collaboration
Specialization
Candidates must possess a minimum of a bachelor's degree in a relevant field and over 6 years of experience in change management, project management, or business transformation, including driving change in digital environments. Strong leadership, communication, and interpersonal skills are essential for influencing stakeholders at all levels.
Experience Required
Minimum 5 year(s)
Renhold-tilkallingsvikarer Trondheim og omegn at Ability
Trondheim, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Daily Cleaning, Periodic Cleaning, Main Cleaning, Service Tasks, Outdoor Maintenance, Indoor Maintenance, Shopping Cart Maintenance, Insta 800 Standard, Service Minded, Flexible, Reliable, Efficient, Responsible, Approachable, Good Humor, Good Physical Shape
Specialization
Candidates should ideally possess a vocational certificate as a cleaning operator or have relevant experience in cleaning, along with familiarity with the INSTA 800 standard. Fluency in Norwegian or English, both spoken and written, and a driver's license are also required.
Senior Marketing Manager at PA Knowledge Limited - Denmark
Oslo, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
B2b Marketing, Integrated Campaigns, Stakeholder Management, Digital Marketing, Event Management, Public Relations, Content Strategy, Commercial Instincts, Strategic Planning, Brand Building, Marketing Operations, Crm, Account Based Marketing, Project Management, Analytical Skills, Communication
Specialization
Candidates must have 4–6 years of B2B marketing experience, preferably within professional services or consulting. Proficiency in both Norwegian and English is required, along with a strong track record in delivering integrated campaigns across digital, PR, and event channels.
Experience Required
Minimum 5 year(s)
Selger 100% Vikariat JYSK Tromsø at JYSK
Tromsø, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Sales, Customer Service, Teamwork, Initiative, Goal Orientation, Flexibility, Positive Energy, Communication In Norwegian, Area Responsibility
Specialization
The ideal candidate is outgoing, enjoys talking to people, possesses positive energy, takes initiative, loves sales, and thrives on working towards common goals. Applicants must be able to understand and be understood in Norwegian and be prepared for evening and Saturday work.
Global Process Owner Record to Report at BearingPoint United Kingdom
Oslo, Oslo, Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Record To Report, Financial Close, General Ledger, Consolidation, Reporting, Sap S/4hana, Ifrs, Process Harmonisation, Process Standardisation, Change Management, Audit, Financial Accounting, Controlling, Signavio, Process Mining, Automation
Specialization
Candidates must hold a master's degree in a business or economics discipline and possess at least five years of professional experience in accounting, controlling, or audit. Strong expertise in SAP S/4HANA, IFRS, and process governance is required, along with fluent English communication skills.
Experience Required
Minimum 5 year(s)
Telecom - Senior/Principal engineer Bergen at Statoil ASA – Norway
Bergen, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Design, Studies, Estimation, Job Packages, Discipline Check, Supplier Follow Up, Pre Test, Fat, Inspections, Training, As Built, Telecom System, Network Infrastructure, Fiber Optic Technologies, Atex, Norsok
Specialization
Candidates need a Bachelor's or Master's degree in Telecom/Instrumentation/Automation, or equivalent technical college degree with extensive experience in Norwegian Oil and Gas engineering projects. A minimum of 5 years of experience in offshore-related projects and strong engineering design skills are required, along with knowledge of relevant industry standards and telecommunication technologies.
Experience Required
Minimum 5 year(s)
Partner Business IT Solutions and Business Development - Northern EU - Insu at SAP Fioneer
, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Business Solution, Business Development, Insurance Industry, C Suite Engagement, Trusted Advisor, Technical Challenge Identification, Business Driver Understanding, Solution Co Creation, Transformation Projects, Portfolio Utilization, Stakeholder Collaboration, Process Analysis, Industry Knowledge, It Solutions, Solution Selling, Business Acumen
Specialization
Candidates must possess a minimum of 8 years of experience delivering IT solutions for strategic and transformational initiatives within insurance companies. Essential qualifications include a Master's degree (MBA/PhD preferred) and deep expertise in Core Insurance software, coupled with a strong network among C-Suite executives in the UK and North Europe.
Experience Required
Minimum 10 year(s)
Joker Reinslettveien søker butikkmedarbeider - deltid at NorgesGruppen
Bodø, Nordland, Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Customer Service, Cashier Work, Stock Replenishment, Physical Stamina, Communication, Teamwork, Problem Solving, Creativity, Retail Operations
Specialization
Candidates must be at least 18 years old and possess strong Norwegian language skills. Previous experience in grocery or retail is preferred but not required, and the ability to work evenings, weekends, and holidays is essential.
KIWI Flymuseet søker etter butikkmedarbeider deltid 80 % at NorgesGruppen
, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Customer Service, Punctuality, Orderliness, Positive Attitude, Work Capacity, Honesty, Responsibility, Reliability, Competitive Instinct
Specialization
Candidates must be at least 18 years old, punctual, and organized. You should possess a positive service attitude, high work capacity, and be honest and responsible.
Senior nettverksingeniør at Sopra Steria
Stavanger, Rogaland, Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Network Engineering, Scripting, Automation, Sd Wan, Vmware Nsx, Cisco Aci, Fortinet, Python, Ansible, Terraform, Network Modernization, Network Optimization, English Communication, Norwegian Communication
Specialization
Candidates should have a higher education degree and 4+ years of relevant experience, preferably with a CCNA certification. Proficiency in automation tools like Python or Ansible and knowledge of SD-WAN or Cisco ACI is highly valued.
Experience Required
Minimum 5 year(s)
Sales Advisor - Oslo Fornebu (sommerhjelp) at Rituals
Bærum, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Customer Experience, Teamwork, Sales Guidance, Visual Merchandising, Safety Procedures, Retail, Customer Service, Problem Solving, Decision Making, Organization, Norwegian, English
Specialization
Candidates must be passionate about creating a magical customer experience, connecting genuinely with customers, and acting as a professional brand ambassador. Required qualifications include relevant retail/customer service/health experience, a results-oriented mindset, strong decision-making skills, attention to detail, and very good proficiency in Norwegian and English.
Securitas søker vekter til NAV kontor (Intern) at Securitas USA Corporate Services
Oslo, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Security Monitoring, Reception Services, Patrol Rounds, Reporting, Incident Handling, Customer Service, Independent Work, Teamwork, Professionalism, Initiative, Structured, Reliable, Technical Aptitude, System Handling
Specialization
The ideal candidate must be independent, confident, mature, proactive, structured, and reliable, possessing a good security mindset to understand client needs and make sound decisions. Fluency in Norwegian and English (minimum B2 for Norwegian) is mandatory, along with a security guard education, clean criminal record, a Class B driver's license, and access to a private car.
Salgsmedarbeider 25% JYSK Sandvika at JYSK
Sandvika, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Customer Service, Sales Activities, Product Knowledge, Cash Register Operation, Merchandising, Stock Management, Teamwork, Communication, Norwegian, English, Physical Stamina
Specialization
Candidates must possess excellent customer service and strong sales skills, along with good communication abilities in both Norwegian and English. The role requires the ability to work in a fast-paced retail environment, handle transactions accurately, and be physically capable of standing for long periods and lifting goods.
Sesonghjelp sommer MATCH Farmandstredet at Decades
Tønsberg, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Customer Service, Sales, Fashion Knowledge, Trend Awareness, Communication, Interpersonal Skills
Specialization
Candidates should have completed high school and possess sales experience within the retail industry. A strong interest in fashion and trends, along with a social and welcoming personality, is required.
Kundekonsulent | Fastlønn + Bonus | Norico AS at Workation AS
Oslo, Oslo, Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Customer Service, Sales, Communication Skills, Order Handling, Relationship Building, Teamwork, Pc Proficiency, Telephone Etiquette
Specialization
Candidates should be outgoing with strong verbal and written communication skills and a service-minded attitude. Experience in customer service is a plus, but the company encourages young applicants eager to learn.
Burger King Orkanger søker fulltidsansatt at Burger King Norge
Orkanger, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Customer Service, Teamwork, Food Preparation, Communication, Initiative, Time Management
Specialization
The candidate should be a positive 'yes-person' who is available to work days, evenings, and weekends. A strong desire to provide 100% effort in guest service is more important than a fancy CV.
Sesonghjelp sommer MATCH Jærhagen at Decades
Klepp, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Customer Service, Sales, Fashion Knowledge, Trend Awareness, Communication, Interpersonal Skills
Specialization
Candidates should have completed high school and possess a strong interest in fashion and trends. Previous sales experience in a similar retail industry is preferred.
Ledig stilling som BPA-assistent: Bli min viktige støttespiller! at Humana omsorg og assistanse
Oslo, , Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Personal Care, Patient Transfer, Communication, Patient Advocacy, Social Activation, Hygiene Care, Feeding Tube Management, Patience, Reliability, Norwegian Language Proficiency
Specialization
Candidates must have strong oral and written Norwegian skills and be comfortable with personal care and lifting equipment. Experience with people with disabilities or wheelchair handling is an advantage but not required as training is provided.
Butikkmedarbeidere i 25% stilling til Musti Jessheim Senter! at Musti Norge AS
Jessheim, Viken, Norway - Full Time
Skills Needed
Sales, Customer Service, Upselling, Animal Care, Teamwork, Communication
Specialization
Candidates must be over 18 with retail experience, preferably in sales, and have a passion for or experience with dogs and cats. An energetic, outgoing personality and a positive attitude toward competition are required.